E-Mail:
Author Avatar

Google Desktop Search Vs Windows Vista Search

Via my friend Todd Bishop at the PI, Google raises Microsoft antitrust concern. I’m linking to his story since the original NYT post requires registration, which is absolutely l4m3.

According to the New York Times report, Google has complained that computers slow significantly when running both Windows Vista’s built-in desktop search program and Google Desktop Search. The behind-the-scenes indexing needed for desktop search programs can drag on computing resources.

There is no simple way for PC users to turn off Windows Vista’s built-in desktop search program. Google has asked the court overseeing Microsoft’s antitrust compliance to require the company to let users turn off the built-in search program, the New York Times reported.

If anything, Google should be thrilled that Windows Vista’s desktop search program is one of the worst out there (sorry, Brandon). I’ve never had near the level of satisfaction with Vista’s search experience - especially compared to Copernic’s elegance. Mind you, I’m no fan of Google’s desktop software, either. Instead of complaining to the DOJ, Google should be working to improve its client - independent of Vista’s shortcomings.

Tags:

4 Comments

I uninstall all desktops and search bars from yahoo, google, msn, etc. They all do nothing but cause problems with computers. If my customers want them, then I tell them I will NOT honor my mean and lean guarantee.

I agree that Vista’s built in search is nowhere near as good or as resource-free as Vista fanboys and Microsoft claim. Still, it is one the few user-level improvements over XP.

Steve Hobberstad

June 13th, 2007
at 7:00am

Users should be aware that according to the documentary “Google-The Power of a Search Engine” every online search conducted by every Google user is PERMANENTLY archived in a huge database being amassed by the company, and while the algorithm Google Desktop uses to search your hard drive locally may be just as slick as the one used to search the Internet this obviously exposes users to privacy issues which are potentially orders of magnitude more serious.

In view of the current administration’s increasing propensity to play fast and loose with governmental limitations and constitutional protections, users need to consider very carefully whether they want to subject themselves to this kind of vulnerability.

Isn’t Google’s point valid? If running both desktop search clients creates a significant “drag” on resources and it is not “simple” for the average user to disable the MS service… wouldn’t average users be steered towards disabling/removing Google’s software?

What Do You Think?

 


Anti-Spam Image

Want to Start a Blog Here for Free?

Are you an expert in one subject or another? If your goal is to help others and dispense hard-earned information back to the community, stake a claim on your very own Lockergnome blog today! You can write about anything - no matter the topic. Sign-up to start blogging!

Author Avatar
Deals - Jul 4, 2008

Celebrating Revolution

Author Avatar
Download, Feedback, Freeware - Jul 2, 2008

Schoolhouse 2: Open Source Boogaloo

Author Avatar
Download, Freeware - Jul 1, 2008

Wubi v8.04