E-Mail:
Get our new Windows 7 eBook (PDF) for $7 with 70+ Tips. Download Now!

Windows 7 Gets More Locked Down

Reported on the Neowin site, more proof that Microsoft wants to lock out 3rd party items in Windows 7.

The latest beta of Windows 7 blocks the usage of third party video decoders from Windows Media Player and MCE. Albain, a DirectShow (ffdshow) developer explains in his own words what he encountered when he was testing the multimedia pipeline of Windows 7 in the latest build 7057.

“Microsoft has locked mpeg4 and h264 codecs into Media Foundation, the replacer of DirectShow (even if directshow is still supported).There is no way to override those codecs, even if you develop a Media Foundation version of your decoder, because Microsoft maintains a list of preferred codecs (their codecs) into the registry (HKEY_CLASSES_ROOT and HKLM \MediaFoundation\Transforms\Preferred), and this registry key cannot be modified, even in admin mode. Only TrustedInstaller user can modify it, which is FYI the user that protects system files, and it cannot be used. Microsoft brought those new codecs, but blocked the possibility to use alternate codecs in their applications.”

Windows Media Center and Windows Media Player users might need to worry whether things would still be the same in Windows 7 RC or whether it might change, even though there are alternative players options.

The E7 team revealed last month that in addition to built in DivX support, Windows Media Player will also natively support the .mov files.

I’m guessing that Microsoft thinks this will avoid any problems with bad code in the media player, but to the public it looks as though Microsoft is locking out developers from making additions to the operating system.

Just now I wonder what the European Union will think of this, not to mention Apple, as apparently QuckTime codecs will no longer work. Perhaps Microsoft will announce that Windows Media Player will also be removable from Windows 7.

The boys in Redmond better get these things very right, or else people will be complaining up and own about the lack of usability. Many videos need a codec that, up until now, Microsoft has not supplied.

Perhaps Microsoft is trying to get out of the utility business, which is just as well, because they don’t do it very well. The media player is not the best, the disk defragmenter is poor, and the Windows Defender has been screwed up since the days of when Microsoft bought it from Giant Software, and usually only defends against things that are wanted.

Will this be the end of the third party tools for Windows? I’m certain that users will do more complaining about loss of compatibility than the manufacturers of those products.

I’m sure that hackers will get around the ‘Trusted Installer’ garbage, with tools to modify the registry while the operating system is not up.

§


I was walking down Fifth Avenue today and I found a wallet, and I was gonna keep it, rather than return it, but I thought: well, if I lost a hundred and fifty dollars, how would I feel? And I realized I would want to be taught a lesson.

– Emo Philips

Digg This

14 Comments

This is just one more reason I’m glad I switched my main computer to a Macintosh.

I’d thought about building a new PC, just for the fun.

By the time it would be finished, I’d probably buy Windows 7.

Now I think I’ll just save up and buy another Macintosh instead.

[...] Windows 7 is getting even more locked down. [...]

It will change you can count on that

[...] More here: Windows 7 Gets More Locked Down ~ Revelations From An Unwashed Brain [...]

micro$ can’t even get the clipboard right.
I use a third party ver. ( m8 multi-clipboard )
Can edit clips and even has a basic editor for photo captures. Can save up to 25 clips.

I’m still using XP Pro and am in the process of building a dedicated machine for Ubuntu.
Except for XP updates, I’m through with micro$!

I would respond to this, but the comments range from unimformed to absurd.

Stop reading forum speculation and go read the development docs, they’re all available at msdn.com

Kitty, strange, because when I look at the Microsoft (any) site(s), all I see is propaganda going from mild to totally outrageous, and FUD.

Hello,

It is important to keep in mind that “build 7057″ is an internal build of Windows 7 that leaked. As such, treating anything in it as official would not be a good idea. Software developers often release test versions of software with features missing or locked down because those areas of the code are not the ones to be tested or because they are unstable outside of the supplied configuration. I suspect this leaked build of Windows 7 is nothing more.

Regards,

Aryeh Goretsky

Hmm, build 7057 leaked…. I think not. If it was leaked, it was an intentional leak. Well, may be not, come to think of it, Microsoft’s internal security may have a lot in common with Windows software security. Poor… at its best.

[...] those new codecs, but blocked the possibility to use alternate codecs in their applications Link http://www.lockergnome.com/theoracle…e-locked-down/   ——————- There are only ten types of people in the world: Those who [...]

This article makes a good point, but I believe that we are all forgetting that what was being tested was only a beta version of the operating system. Apparently if the incompatibility of third party stuff irritates the consumers, Microsoft will most definitely NOT make them incompatible (or most of them anyway). I believe that, while this information is useful, we underestimate the manufacturers’ logic.

Squeakurs, let me put it this way… Windows 3.0, Microsoft Bob, Windows Me, Vista - do you see a pattern? I coiuld start further back, and include DOS 4.0 - so bad that Microsoft had to really hustle to get DOS 4.01 out, because the problems were so bad.

I don’t think anyone would lose money by underestimating the logic of Microsoft - because there is very little.

We speak of how complex all the problems are, trying to make certain that an operating system works with hardware and other software, which is true - but then if Microsoft had such intelligence, the company wouldn’t repeat the same errors over and over.

I certainly hope win7 won’t block 3rd party video applications. I never use WMP and prefer VLV or MPC with other codec supports. WMP is horribly bloated and insists on helping me by calling home constantly. The third party video players do just what I need done and no more.

Perhaps the apparent lockdown is the continuing effort for DRM controls. Eventually the industry will understand that DRM is impossible to achieve.

HarryH, it is really going to depend if those players get programmed to install in the prescribed Microsoft manner.

Microsoft is so busy saving everyone from everything that soon it will be saving us all from using Windows. (When you make something idiotproof, only idiots will want to use it.)

What Do You Think?

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Posted Recently

49 queries / 0.970 seconds.