From itwire.com is the news that Dell has started putting the latest revision of Ubuntu Linux on some of its computers, Gutsy Gibbon, or 7.10. What is the newsworthy part is that Dell has decided to put some non - open source, non - free software on the computers.
There are two packages being shipped on the machines now, which are not a part of the distribution. One is the Adobe Flash player, which seems innocuous, as it is a truly free item, and almost everyone who surfs the net comes upon a site that needs it to render all that is on the pages. The other item is a non - free player from InterVideo, the LinDVD player.
Already there are users who have seen fit to decry the practice of mixing this non - free software into the distribution. This isn’t going to win any friends for Dell when the rest of the purists get the word on this.
The article goes on, however, to show that perhaps Dell is making a deal with InterVideo to spice up its distribution, and make it special for buyers of Dell computers.
The LinDVD page says “LinDVD, InterVideo’s Linux software DVD player, is currently available only to manufacturers for evaluation and integration.” Is this only legally available to Dell owners then?
“It looks like Dell wants to create a DellOS distro based on Ubuntu with various of proprietary things in the mix (ala Linspire) to help sell their computers. There’s nothing stopping them from doing that, but is it really fair for Dell to be calling this “Ubuntu” though?”
I fully understand where Limulus is coming from. However, having run into the problem of trying to install DVD playback on Ubuntu myself, I can also appreciate Dell’s point of view. The problem for Dell as I see it is that it wants to sell Linux PCs that can be used out of the box. After all, that’s the idea of selling pre-installed Ubuntu PCs - no? If a PC with an optical drive can’t even play back encrypted DVDs when you take delivery and switch it on then it is not a fully functional computer compared to a Windows or Mac box.
Getting an Ubuntu box to play encrypted DVDs is not rocket science. You just have to download the required codecs from the Ubuntu software repository. The problem is that because of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act this is illegal in the US - most Ubuntu users in the US do it anyway. For US company Dell, however, it would appear that there is no way the company can legally give its customers plug and play DVD playback other than bundling a proprietary solution like LinDVD (please correct me if I’m wrong).
I don’t think this is such a big thing - if all the legal problems are scienced out - Dell could make a really nice profit if the money spent on a Windows license was spent instead on workability solutions for Linux, so that the ‘everyman’ could get working as soon as all the cords are plugged in.
-
| Share this post : |
Tags: ubuntu 7.10, gutsy gibbon, dell computers, intervideo lindvd

Blu-ray- superior format, favored by some of the movie studios, and HD DVD, a good format, with lower requirements, and its own legion of followers. Now there’s no need to choose!
LG brings the formats together for those who don’t want to be left out of any action!
LG BH200 - a dual format winner! Quality movies no matter what the studio affiliation!
HDMI connection included on the player (like the one on this video card)- making it easily connected to your large computer LCD or television.