Five Reasons Why We Are Not Ready for a World Without Cash or Credit Cards

Posted by on Nov 4, 2011 | 11 Comments

Does anyone remember the paperless office and why that didn’t work? How about the predictions back in the 1960s that one day our cars would be driving themselves down our roadways while we sat reading a book? These and other predictions never came to pass because we as a society were not ready for them. Yesterday, I read with interest an article on the Slate site that seemed to suggest that a new application called Card Case would make cash and credit cards obsolete.

Here are five reasons why I personally believe that this will not happen:

  • Since before the time of Christ, coins have been used to barter for the exchange of goods and services. Later paper money was introduced and became an accepted form of payment, used throughout the world, for the purchase of goods and services. Later still, credit cards were introduced. Because of the fees attached to these cards, however, some businesses still refuse to honor them — meaning that cash still remains king. (That’s something anyone in a drug cartel will attest to!)
  • To totally become a cashless or credit cardless society, every store and business would need to upgrade their systems to handle applications of every kind, including everything from purchases to paying their own bills. Therefore, in a time of economic uncertainty such as we are currently experiencing, I would doubt that all businesses would be in the financial position to do this any time soon.
  • Not everyone has a smart phone or is able to afford to purchase one, which would mean that they would be unable to make purchases or pay their monthly mortgage. In my opinion, businesses and stores would not want to alienate an entire segment of society just because they did not have the financial ability to purchase a smart phone.
  • Then you have to consider those individuals who have bad or no credit. How could these individuals qualify to use an application without a secured account to insure payment for the purchases they make? Remember that these consumers are the ones who rely on payday loan payment centers that cater to the segment of our society that lives paycheck to paycheck.
  • Additionally, these cards could lead to higher prices. For instance, today when we use a credit card, the merchant pays a fee for the transaction through the credit card company or bank.Therefore, if an individual could not pay with cash and credit cards were discontinued, every transaction via a smart phone application would have to carry a fee of some type. This means if you bought a pack of gum, a candy bar, or that favorite latte, all would need to be charged higher fees for purchases.

Personally, I would prefer having an application on my smart phone to make purchases of any kind, but the reality is that I seriously doubt that this program will garner any kind of public support since it seems impossible that cash or credit cards will disappear overnight.

Comments welcome.

  • http://twitter.com/tsilb Kevin Connolly

    Funny, we did just fine without them until 1933.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102

    • Anonymous

      Christian, Similar to Pay-Pay where the amount is taken from a savings or checking account would work for me. 

  • Christian Lewis

    I personally would love to see my iPhone become my credit card too. Although, I would prefer it was more like a pre-paid account, where it only takes money from my bank balance, which I am sure would be optional.

  • Anonymous

    Funny how you think because a person refuses to carry credit, they are beholden to a payday loan company, its called living within your means Chris. Maybe you should try it. The fact that someone can decide your credit worthiness is why capitalism doesn’t half assed work. A lot of people, ordinary Americans, live on what they make, not an imaginary credit score. Your way of thinking is why things don’t change, its sad but expected.

    • http://chris.pirillo.com/ Chris Pirillo

      Chris who?

  • Anonymous

    Chris, I believe when our dollar goes into hyper inflation, it will be a perfect opportunity for a new currency to move into its place (IE: Bitcoin).  If that becomes the new standard, everyone will get a device to felicitate the transaction.

  • D Lowrey

    Another huge flaw in this plan…especially in the US where banks…other financial institutions and merchants refuse to take responsibility for their lack of concern about security and do what they can to actively combat ID theft…your portable device would become a hackers dream and your nightmare.

  • Richard Schmitt

    Using cash may cease someday.  Have to take a long term view.   The important questions are do we want to remove the control of the economy from the US government?  How will the federal reserve tamper down inflation (remember that condition?) by moderating the amount of cash in circulation?   Will the savings from having to print and mint money result in lower taxes which savings will be paid to the owners of the cell phone technology?

  • Kathy Pop

     I think eventually we will become nearly cashless. I think businesses will be, but what about people who sell things thru the classifieds or garage sales? How would this work for them?
     
     I’ve been a victim of identity theft in the past, and now use a prepaid debit card for purchases so there is no attachment to my bank account.I only pay a small flat fee for using it, so I’m not so sure that this won’t be an option in the future. I rarely carry any significant cash on me and I have used my debit card to buy a soda. Will prices go up- maybe a few cents.

  • Kathy Pop

     I think eventually we will become nearly cashless. I think businesses will be, but what about people who sell things thru the classifieds or garage sales? How would this work for them?
     
     I’ve been a victim of identity theft in the past, and now use a prepaid debit card for purchases so there is no attachment to my bank account.I only pay a small flat fee for using it, so I’m not so sure that this won’t be an option in the future. I rarely carry any significant cash on me and I have used my debit card to buy a soda. Will prices go up- maybe a few cents.

  • Kyle Polansky

    This is a good point, and I have a suggestion that would fix all this, but at the same time hurt the technology industry very hard. What if phones were controlled by the government? This would allow a universal standard for everything, and would ensure everyone would be able to have one. On the down side. Software companies like Android would be out of business.