5 Myths About HDTV

Posted by on Dec 1, 2010 | 52 Comments

This is the time of the year when millions of Americans will be shopping for their first HDTV. Over at The Blade I have written an article about what to look for in buying a HDTV and this article is a follow-up to the original. IMO it is important for all consumers to know the terminology of HDTV technology and also to know what is Fact and What is fiction before buying your first HDTV.

Here are five myths about HDTV you should be aware of:

1. Claim: “HD” signifies a specific standard of quality.

Status: False

Though “HD” does stand for “high definition,” HDTVs come in several resolutions; and in any event, a set’s resolution doesn’t completely determine the exact image quality you’ll see on your screen. For one thing, screen sizes vary. Other factors affecting the picture include the transmission—over the air, via cable, by satellite, or from the Internet—and the original source material.

These variables help explain why you can get high-def content from Amazon, Hulu, iTunes, Netflix streaming, a Blu-ray disc, and other sources, and yet encounter wildly different picture quality.

Over-the-air broadcast standards top out at 720p and 1080i, but you can obtain the full 1920-by-1080-pixel frame in 1080p from Blu-ray discs, certain Xbox 360 models, and the PlayStation 3 units.

When choosing for picture quality, remember: 1080p is at the top, 720p and 1080i look similar, and anything below them won’t be as good. Keep those terms in mind because they represent official standards, not marketing terms.

I don’t know if I can make this any less painless, but I’ll try. 1080p is the very best picture you can currently receive on a HDTV. This highest standard is basically limited to Blu-ray movies. All over the air transmissions, whether they are received by antenna, cable or satellite are currently limited to 720p.

However, if you are watching a HD broadcast of an old black and white movie, you may notice little or no difference in the picture quality.

2. Claim: If you don’t buy a 1080p HDTV, you’re wasting your money.

Status: False

In all likelihood, you want a 1080p HDTV—and you should be sure to get that resolution if your set has a diagonal screen size of 32 inches or greater, since you’ll be able to see the additional resolution on a big-screen from across the room. Furthermore, there’s no reason to avoid a 1080p HDTV if it doesn’t cost substantially more than sets with alternative resolutions, given that 1080p is becoming ubiquitous. If the difference is within $100, I recommend going for a 1080p set if your budget can handle it.

But having said all that, I should warn you that you probably won’t see any improvement in picture quality from 1080p versus 720p on a smaller HDTV. And you may not even have any 1080p sources to exploit: Over-the-air broadcasts and most cable feeds top out at 1080i.

I personally own two 42″ plasma HDTV’s which both are limited to 720p. The picture quality is fine when watching broadcast TV or playing DVD’s. If you plan on buying a large HDTV and hooking up a Blu-ray player, go with 1080p HDTV.

3. Claim: You bought a HDTV, so everything you view will be in HD.

Status: False

Today, not everything on television is broadcast in high-definition. DVDs and shows that were recorded for broadcast under the prior analog standard will continue to look about the same as before. (Some HDTV sets even make old shows look worse, by showing off more imperfections of the original recording.)

For satellite or cable TV service, you may need to ask your provider to activate HD content. The transition might require setup on both the provider’s end and your end; some cable boxes need to be reconfigured to output HD signals even after you connect them with the proper cables.

This can be a real disappointment for those who do not have access to broadcast TV or have a cable company that doesn’t provide broadcasts in HDTV. I went through this when I lived in an area where the cable company did not provide HD broadcasts and I was to far away to receive over the air TV.

4. Claim: Brand-name cables are worth the extra money.

Status: False

Don’t buy cables strictly on the basis of their brand name. A cable’s connector type, length, and gauge are the most important factors in signal quality. As a first criterion, choose a digital cable if possible—either HDMI or DVI (just about any new HDTV will include a digital connection). Such cables can carry a 1080p signal if your content supports it, they’ll play nicely with DRM, and they won’t pick up interference the way an analog cable can.

This is the best advice you will receive. HDMI cables can be purchased for as little as $7 and will provide a great picture.

5. Claim: You’re in imminent danger of burn-in from letterboxing and on-screen graphics.

Status: False

Burn-in is no longer a serious issue for HDTVs. Years ago, static on-screen graphics from network TV logos, stock tickers, videogames, letterbox bars, and other patterns could wear unevenly on a TV. If you left your set on and tuned to a station that showed such stationary elements for hours at a time, you might have been able to see them lingering when you tried to watch other content. First-generation plasma screens were the ones most susceptible to this effect.

LCDs and other TV types haven’t exhibited this issue, and recent plasmas have incorporated effective countermeasures against the problem. If you’re buying a new set, don’t worry about burn-in.

Do you have any suggestions you would like to share?

Comments welcome.

Source – Macworld

  • Cliffystones

    How ’bout?

    “HDTV does not improve acting, story lines or plot development.”

    • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

      Hi Cliffystones,
      True, very true! LOL

  • D

    Living in Southern Idaho where all the stations are digital…several are still being broadcast in 480i. Having a couple of TV tuners…I get to see the quality of what I record. 480i broadcasts are of such low quality that I don’t even waste my time recording them…much less watching them. The reason…you can tell the difference on a decent 720p TV.

  • http://twitter.com/sobercool Eric T.

    Thank You. At the tip of my nose all my life and now you tell me how easy it is.

  • http://twitter.com/bsousmusic b.sous music

    Okay, This is quite frustrating. The option for “action” in my inbox is not there and I can not remove myself from conversation.

  • http://twitter.com/bsousmusic b.sous music

    Okay, This is quite frustrating. The option for “action” in my inbox is not there and I can not remove myself from conversation.

  • http://twitter.com/bsousmusic b.sous music

    Okay, This is quite frustrating. The option for “action” in my inbox is not there and I can not remove myself from conversation.

  • Anonymous

    Nice gift. The video was great and if you choose me, I would appreciate it. I am a disabled veteran and would be handy for my computers.

  • Zachary McIlvoy

    did you pirillo YouTube!!? it wont let me post…

  • Manish Agarwal

    Excellent video – really like the earnestness, Chris!

  • John Baker

    Dude, I So need a 1.5 T external! If you and Seagate could hook me up that would be a real blessing.

  • http://twitter.com/SF_Living Suzi Kissinger

    love seagate.. love this solution. Sad story, I killed my HD on my HP laptop while in the middle of a client transaction.. :( switched to my MAC, and on the hunt for, finally!, a backup HD. A Free one would work with my budget!

  • http://www.facebook.com/blakeaweber Blake Weber

    Love the seagate products. I have a desktop model and the bus optons are great.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=519317456 John Cone

    seagate is pretty awesome — I have never had any problems with their drives — and CHRIS LOVE the vids — I have been following you from way back in the day like since 1998 a fellow midwesterner (i am from the dakotas)

  • Chuck Cortes

    Chris comes thru as usual. The dude rocks and this drive has enough space to carry all his videos with you. :)

  • http://twitter.com/rockcampbell Dave Campbell

    I could really use one of those.

  • http://twitter.com/fixgadget FixGadget

    I’ll take one. All my drives are Seagate with the exception of a WD Live NAS I picked up for $80 @ BB.

  • http://twitter.com/fixgadget FixGadget

    I cracked open one of my WD Essentials external USB drive I purchased a few years ago and it had a Seagate 250GB drive in it.

  • l m larson

    ooh, I good place to keep all of my art / music / books !!!

  • http://twitter.com/ElviraGallegos Elvira Gallegos

    As an unemployed student, I could really use this harddrive for my upcoming Sound Design class. It would be great to have something like that to hold and store all my class multimedia projects (which take up a lot of space). I love Seagate!!

  • http://twitter.com/JHCDigital Jesse Catlin

    Just got a new Macbook Pro and this would be a perfect accessory!

  • http://twitter.com/mkartchner Michael Kartchner

    Great review, and I am a big believer in Time Machine!!!

  • http://twitter.com/dhubbart Dustin Hubbart

    Please send it my way! I will take it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/wa0zog Mike Miller

    Nice looking drive! I like the form factor, especially for that amount of storage space. It would certainly be a handy addition to the laptop bag.

  • Raven-Christopher Richardson

    Sounds great!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=568030957 Dan Reain

    Thanks, please put me in the running!

  • http://twitter.com/computerbugg Ken Buxton

    Add me

  • Abel Luna

    Awesome. Giveaway

  • Sarah Doxiadis

    Chris,

    Giveaways and discounts really help your fellow geeks have useful geek tools, and give them the hands-on experience to try new products and spread the good words to the less geeky. Thanks to you for sharing. (Well, yes, this is a bit of a suck-up, but I really mean it! I wouldn’t say so if I didn’t think highly of both the man and the brand currently in discussion.)

    Ahh, love those self-powered drives! Just got a new (refurb) iMac and really need to replace my ageing Seagate wall-powered backup with a self-powered one that I could attach to my Airport Extreme. At last, my tiny, cramped desk would have some space on it! (I keep the Airport Extreme up on a dedicated “wireless” shelf above my desk.)

    I could use the older Seagate drive as a dedicated backup to my BootCamp volume, which needs less storage space and right now gets backed up a bit haphazardly onto a groaning thumbdrive.

  • Anonymous

    that would look sweet on my desk!!

  • http://twitter.com/techrob53 Robert Kimball

    Awesome, and no better deal than FREE.

  • Anonymous

    Yes please. Great video Chris. Thanks.

  • http://www.facebook.com/piscitell Jon Piscitell

    I could really use the drive. Mine just died, luckily I was able to back the data up to my friends computer but now he wants his space back.

  • http://twitter.com/Poochiepants David Boyer

    I was listening to some Daft Punk while I was watching your video. Good mashup.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=704780586 Rachel Jenkins

    Sweet! Nice giveaway. I would love to win this for my friend.

  • http://twitter.com/MJHProduction Mark J Hewitt

    Hey Chris,

    Great drive would love it :-) I just sold my T2i and purchased a new T3i and thought I would share with you that you can only record videos for 12 mins due to over heating and 4 gb file size limitation. So if you don’t mind recording and then shutting off your camera and then turning it back on then its a great camera.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UQWQX4CR6D75J7NVWU6NJSPUY4 Eddie Shafer

    Thanks for sponsoring the giveaway!

  • http://twitter.com/gemelv George M.

    This old guy would really like that great piece of technology. Thanks Chris.

  • http://twitter.com/BrijeshMehetre Brijesh Mehetre

    Give it to me.. I need it..

  • http://www.facebook.com/ag.wright1 Allen Wright

    Nice size for a portable drive. I’m still trying to fill my 350 gig drive.

  • Ronald Gerard

    Have One Of these, smaller tho; NOT a bad drive as external.

  • Anonymous

    Please give it to me; I am in need of a means of storage for ‘all’ my music and photographs. This harddrive is amazing and so compact. Very good explanaiton Chris. Thumbs up to you.

  • Robin Potter

    Wow Chris! The drive would be a great addition to my network and allow me to have extreme storage for all of my videos, photos and other graphics.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7XOXRXB4UWXJWO7JMTBCH73QQU R

    Been needing a new external drive. Had concerns about Seagate Drives. However, this sounds like a terrific drive and investment. Thanks Chris!

  • Anonymous

    Have save a lot of your newsletters and links. Ineed a place to put them. Put me in the running

  • http://www.facebook.com/digitalrico Ricky Cardio

    cool! i need this!

  • Adrion Winterhart

    I really like the idea of a external without needing a power supply as well. In school for Interactive Media Design, so extra storage space would awesome. Yes, use the camera. Give one away too!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002401708123 Kyle Stodard

    I really love it and I hope I get it for my Mac. I am a student that works on movies and my old verbatim (NEVER BUY VERBATIM!!) Broke and would love to get this for my Mac.

  • Anonymous

    Hi Chris:

    Nice job on the video. It’s amazing how much storage you can get now. By the way you never seem to age….you look the same as when I first saw you long ago!

  • John Crudden

    I like the idea of a giveaway. It perks my interest. The video explained the drive very well. Even if I don’t get a free one, I will look to purchase one. John.

  • Jack Pangborn

    Most assuredly a positive comment

  • http://www.facebook.com/stepanik Aaron Stepanik

    Never had any NAS device before. Would be nice to get something to try.