Screaming Child On Airplane Causes Woman To Go Deaf

Posted by on Jul 26, 2010 | 11 Comments

Qantas Airline Sued After Screaming Child Causes Woman To Go Deaf

A passenger on a Qantas flight in Australia was taken off of the flight after she starting bleeding from her ear. The woman stated she lost her hearing, which was caused by a screaming three-year-old child. The woman was treated at a local hospital where it was determined that she was rendered deaf in one ear. She eventually sued the airline, which made an out-of-court settlement with the woman.

The article also stated the following:

The boy allegedly leaned back over his armrest toward Ms Barnard and let out a scream so severe that blood erupted from her ears, leaving her “stone cold deaf”.

No other passengers were injured.

Qantas referred to emails allegedly written by Ms Barnard to a travel companion prior to the Australian trip in which she admitted wearing hearing aids, and submitted a volatile email Ms Barnard allegedly wrote a day after the incident to the US travel agent who booked the trip.

“I guess we are simply fortunate that my eardrum was exploding and I was swallowing blood. Had it not been for that, I would have dragged that kid out of his mother’s arms and stomped him to death. Then we would have an ‘international incident’,” Ms Barnard allegedly wrote.

Also at issue was the fact that the woman who lost her hearing was wearing hearing ads, which the airline believed showed she had previous hearing loss. What is unknown is if the child’s mother was also part of the lawsuit.

What do you think? Should the airline have been held accountable for the screaming child?

Comments welcome.

Source – news.com.au

  • JFK

    What happens if your iPod causes you to go deaf. Can you sue?

    • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

      I think you will have to check with Steve Jobs first.

  • http://www.facebool.com/peter.furey Peter Furey

    this needs further proofreading. But other than that good post!

  • Kyle Hulton

    I think it says somewhere in iTunes somewhere about the volume control when your altering setting for your iPod… I don’t know really, not used this shuffle in years… I don’t use a Zune either… I don’t listen to music… I have a poor life… jk xD

  • http://www.gavinstipsandtricks.co.nr/ Gavin Roskamp

    Heh. Heheheh. HEHEHEHEHEH!

    Sorry, that just kinda makes me laugh. I don’t think she can sue Quantas for the problem. Sue the mother, sue the company that made the hearing aids, but Quantas had nothing to do with it. Quantas is an awesome airline. Like mega-awesome. Don’t sue them.

  • Ewan McLean

    Sue both the mother and the airline. The mother is legally responsible and qantas violated it’s duty of care. Simples

  • Pog

    Reading the word quantas is making me dumb not deaf ..

  • Pingback: Facebook Working to Make Account Removal Easier ~ Chris Pirillo

  • Danstransky

    He’ll probably just say your holding it wrong.

  • WereBo

    Ultimately, the parent(s) are responsible for their kid(s) .

    Approach the parent(s) first then, if there’s no luck (or more likely, a mouthful of abuse), complain to the airline staff threatening to follow-up with lawsuits etc.

  • http://twitter.com/EricsFamous Eric’s Energy Co.

    Like this article, thanks.
    Please try our blue widget – Eric’s Famous Energy. You can find them at QFC and at cafes and independents in the Seattle area. Thanks!