Bluetooth Vs. Wireless USB Receivers

wirelessBuying a wireless keyboard and/or mouse doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re going to get a Bluetooth device. Even with the majority of today’s laptops being built with Bluetooth integration, there are still a great many people who have systems which don’t support the standard.

For that matter, Bluetooth isn’t exactly a consistent standard at all. Not every device is Bluetooth 4.0 capable, just as not every device has the same architecture. Motorola, Broadcom, Toshiba, and even Microsoft have slight differences in their Bluetooth products that sometimes introduce issues for the user. Likewise, not every receiver is capable of holding a signal across the same distance as the next.

It’s for these reasons that companies like Logitech have opted to create their own hardware receiver which utilizes the USB port in order to send and receive signals from their products. This is a proprietary technology, and not everyone wants to give up a USB port to use it.

Advantage of a Wireless USB Receiver

In the case of Logitech, a Unifying receiver enables the user to connect up to six compatible devices to a single receiver. That receiver is small enough to remain plugged into a laptop without risking damage from snags or placing it in a bag. The receiver itself has a great range, which in my home extends across a mid-sized room, and rarely experiencing signal drop during normal use. In fact, after using wireless Logitech products for over a year, I have never had a dropped signal while the device is in the same room as the computer.

Most proprietary receivers share similar connectivity themes, with some variances. Modern receivers work on the same 2.4 GHz channel as Bluetooth, and as such can be susceptible to the same interference by many household electronics.

Advantages of a Bluetooth Receiver

Bluetooth adds the benefit of being compatible with more devices. You can sync many Bluetooth accessories to a number of different devices including tablets and mobile phones. You also don’t lose a USB port in the process, which for many laptop users is a very useful feature. Most Bluetooth-capable devices have their receivers built right in and can transmit data to multiple gadgets at once.

Unlike proprietary wireless receivers, Bluetooth doesn’t require you to carry around an extra object along with your mouse and/or keyboard. It just plugs in and works, with minimal drain to the battery.

In the end, it comes down to preference. I like the stability of a dedicated receiver, but can also appreciate the convenience of a Bluetooth connection. Either way, these are two technologies you should be aware of when buying a wireless device. Not all devices without wires are Bluetooth enabled.

Image: Breahn Foster

Article Written by

Ryan Matthew Pierson has worked as a broadcaster, writer, and producer for media outlets ranging from local radio stations to internationally syndicated programs. His experience includes every aspect of media production. He has over a decade of experience in terrestrial radio, Internet multimedia, and commercial video production.

  • Bildo

    Just pondered this yesterday. Why the dongles when BT is there

  • http://profiles.google.com/rysliv ryan haz

    You loose a bit of battery run time with bluetooth. Though I’m sure you loose a tiny bit either way, At least my laptop supports BT 4.0, so it shouldn’t use much power.

    • http://www.techmansworld.com/ Michael Hazell

      You use battery life either way, being that a USB port supplies about 5 volts of current.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1430310093 Wolfee Darkfang

    I got a Button Bluethooth dongle that plugs into a USB port in the back of my desktop. It has a rather short range though. My desktop doesn’t have a built in adapter, so I have to use a USB port. It’s useful for keyboards and mice, but I mostly use it to load custom ringtones to my android. I prefer BT for convenience. For my mouse and keyboard, since this is a desktop and I don’t move them very often, I still use wired for those so I don’t have to buy batteries.

    • http://www.techmansworld.com/ Michael Hazell

      Have you ever heard of AirDroid? I think that this might have been a better option for you without having to buy an extra dongle.

      • Avatar

        Yeah, Bluetooth to transfer files to a phone? What year is it again? 2003?