Microsoft Heads To The Cloud, Google Says The Desktop Is DOA, What Does This All Mean?

Posted by on Mar 5, 2010 | 7 Comments

During the past few days we have been reading about several different approaches for the future of computing that appear to have a common theme. Or are the themes the same?

On one hand we have a memo from the head honcho of Microsoft, Steve Ballmer, telling his people that the company needs to embrace the cloud. In a small excerpt of his memo he states that:

My goal was to challenge people to look at the cloud more broadly and understand the multidimensional nature of the cloud transformation happening today. Other companies have defined the cloud in a narrow, one-dimensional way. Although these companies provide some interesting components, Microsoft is uniquely delivering on a wide range of cloud capabilities that bring increasingly more value to our customers.

To keep our momentum, it is critical that  every Microsoft employee works to deliver the full benefits of the cloud to our customers.

Of course, there is more work to do. We have strong competitors. We need to be (and are) willing to change our business models to take advantage of the cloud. We must move at “cloud speed,” especially in our consumer offerings. And we need to be crystal clear about the value we provide to all our customers.

Over at Google, the head of their European division made a startling statement, in which he has made a prediction that the desktop PC as we now know it, will be dead in 3 years.  His statement stunned his audience when John Herlihy of Google Europe said:

“In three years time, desktops will be irrelevant. In Japan, most research is done today on smart phones, not PCs,” Herlihy told a baffled audience, echoing comments by Google CEO Eric Schmidt at the recent GSM Association Mobile World Congress 2010 that everything the company will do going forward will be via a mobile lens, centring on the cloud, computing and connectivity.

So what does this all mean?

I believe that we are heading towards an era when small devices such as smart phones, mini laptops and other future devices will be using an operating system that may not be powered by Windows. There is a possibility that these devices could be powered by a derivative of Linux such as what Google is using in their new Chromium operating system. The devices will no longer ‘boot’ in the traditional sense and will most likely be instant on devices. Storage in the traditional sense will be limited and the devices will be using cloud computing to store your stuff on a companies server. The traditional hard disk will die and the newer SSD will be replacing these mechanical devices.

So will this all happen in the next 3 years? I seriously doubt it will. For any of us Window users who have tried Linux, we know the obstacles that must be over come to get people to make the switch to something they are not familiar with. Though I applaud Google and their attempts to come up with an alternative to Windows, it is still unknown exactly what Chromium will be and how well it will work for the average home user.

The problems with cloud computing come down to trust. Will we trust any company to store our data on their servers? How safe will our stuff be if we do? Will our data be hack proof?

These and other questions remain. I believe that a 3 year prediction of the death of the PC is self serving and wishful thinking on Google’s part.

Just my two cents.

What do you think?

Comments as always are welcome.

Source – Microsoft memo

Source – PC will be DOA

  • Dick

    Cloud? Didn’t we fight against this very thing when we were all using terminals on a server? Don’t any of you remember that (rhetorical question)? Trust my information to someone else? You’re kidding, right? My media hard drives sit in slide in racks so I can remove them and walk out the door within a few seconds. I have two 1.5tb drives that I keep synchronized to each other so if one fails I have another ready to go. ALL my media is on these drives. My system, program and data files are imaged weekly to a portable USB drive sitting on my desk. It fits in my shirt pocket.
    Write an essay on a portable device???? Render family movies on an I-phone??? Burn a quick CD for someone on your …whatever??? Open a 150 page document? Draw? Calculate? Desktop publish? Edit video or audio? Create slide shows? Do research on a 3″ screen? I’m no longer in the work force but just a couple of years ago, I would be opening 2,000 plus page help files and inserting media, links, etc. into them. Want to do that on an Android?
    It sounds like the loudest voices are galloping geeks who roam their towns tweeting, texting, and otherwise wasting their time. This can essentially be done with 2 cans and a piece of string. This is only a movement if you consider it in the laxative sense.

    • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

      Hello Dick,
      Great points. I seriously doubt that we will see serious computer users buying into this hype. No matter who is pushing it.

      The cloud would be fine for the average user who’s entire life is spent using the computer as a toy and who has never done any serious work on the system.

  • Bruce

    Microsoft missed the internet revolution. Microsoft missed the search revolution. Microsoft missed the social networking revolution. Now Microsoft is making up a cloud computer revolution that will likely never exist so it can be the Calvary leading the charge . Cloud computing has a few advantages but I don’t believe it will ever fully replace the laptop or desktop for all the excellent reasons Dick mentioned. The only cloud computing I plan on doing is after my cold dead fingers are pried off my laptop!

  • http://www.twitter.com/mackenziepricee mackenziepricee

    I still will never trust my files (except for emails) of any kind in the cloud. Sorry!

  • http://blogs.msdn.com/rjohri Rahul Johri

    I work at Microsoft and I would like to try to address the queries people have around Cloud Computing and Microsoft’s view on it.

    As Ron raised a concern about the trust for storing data, I would like to share that the Windows Azure Platform and Windows Azure benefit from the security capabilities afforded by the Microsoft Global Foundation Services’ (GFS) infrastructure. The GFS assurances are validated by external auditors on a regular basis and include a comprehensive security program that covers the entire delivery stack. Microsoft has earned the ISO 27001:2005 accreditation and SAS Type I and Type II attestations for the Microsoft cloud infrastructure (http://www.globalfoundationservices.com/security/documents/SecuringtheMSCloudMay09.pdf)

    Also, Bruce mentioned about the cloud computer revolution in which Microsoft is playing a vital role today. Companies like Kelley Blue Book, Risk Metrics, Thuzi, Invensys and AWS have been among the early investors of Windows Azure platform. Windows Azure platform not only reduces IT related cost for an Enterprise, but also enables applications with a high performance to price ratio by running them on service platform datacenters on a pay-as-you-go basis. It also offers a wide range of choices in user experience over web/connected PC, server and mobile for the ISV’s.

    • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

      Thanks Rahul for dropping by and providing us with this information. It is very much appreciated.
      Regards, Ron

  • http://blogs.msdn.com/rjohri Rahul Johri

    No problem Ron.
    I am glad to help and provide you with the details.

    Thanks,
    Rahul