Bloggers Revolt As FTC Sticks To Its New Regulations
It seems that the media and bloggers are united in an effort to have the FTC review its current guidelines when it comes to social media. The FTC suggests that its new rules are an effort to control and enforce honest and unbiased reviews that are not misleading. A recent article states:
“Although the [Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB)] contends the FTC’s Endorsement Guides are unconstitutional, the Guides apply only to marketing and they attempt to illustrate some of the factors relevant to distinguishing advertising from editorial content,” says Mary Engle, the FTC’s director of the division of advertising practices, in an email statement released today. “If particular communications do not in fact constitute advertising, as the IAB appears to be suggesting, then the Guides do not apply. Where the message is advertising, however, disseminators have an obligation to ensure it is not misleading. This includes, when it is not otherwise clear from the context, identifying when the endorser has been paid for the endorsement. Although IAB may disagree with the policy, nothing in this approach is unconstitutional,” Engle re-iterated.
In a response to the FTC ruling from the Interactive Advertising Bureau it states:
The request for the FTC retraction, written by Randall Rothenberg, president and CEO of the Interactive Advertising Bureau, a group that represents more than 375 media and tech companies including AOL, Google, MSN, and The New York Times Digital, also called for the commission to begin anew with “a fair and open process,” this time with more input from bloggers and other social media professionals. Read the full letter here.
In submitting the letter, the IAB joins the chorus of bloggers and pundits arguing that the new guidelines punish new media. “One of the extremely real effects of these rules is to dry up a flow of opportunity to solo media entrepreneurs without touching offline media professionals,” says Rothenberg.
Some have previously suggested that the FTC is not going to be able to enforce its rules because of the magnitude of the amount of bloggers and social media currently on the Internet. I tend to agree.
Comments welcome.

4 Comments
Urban Underbrink
October 19th, 2009
at 8:17am
Either stand up for your Rights or the Thugs in control will take them from you!
Justen
October 19th, 2009
at 8:37am
Do we really need government thugs at our doors with guns telling us which products we can or cannot endorse and how we can do it? Are people so stupid as to require know-nothings hidden in a dark, dirty cubicle in some bureau office deciding what is safe for them to view and backing it up with pigs and guns? Come on. This is just an inroad for bigg businesses with the manpower and motivation to go scanning the ‘net and squishing favorable press for their competition. They’re externalizing the costs of leg-breaking to the taxpayer because they can’t or don’t wish to compete on an honest market, and they’re selling it on populism. Scum, scum and scum.
Joe2G
October 19th, 2009
at 10:17am
Would this affect Lockergnome ? Will Chris have to mark **ADVERTISEMENT** on his links for his e-book plugs, and on gotoassist and solarwinds ? Currently, they almost appear (but I am sure most gnomies have learned not to fall for them) to be legit articles. Chris’ ‘70 windows 7 tips’ changes titles and appears to be an article, whereas you know that the others are external (outside LG) links.
I am not begrudging Chris money from the links, but deception on the web is rampant, and I hate to see this BLOG perpetuate that trap. Mark the link clearly that you are a paid mouthpiece for the item/article/opinion and we will know it is an advert.
I think Lockergnome has enough respect that if I am looking here and see an ad for a product / service I need, then I will go to it. But to disguise it as an informative link just makes me suspicious and wary – and then I tend to not buy from that vendor or I drop the publication that felt the need to decieve.
DizzyTheKid
October 19th, 2009
at 1:37pm
I THINK WE NEED TO REVOLT WITH FORCE AGAINST THE F.T.C.! WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH WITH YOUR MIND NUMBING ADVERTISMENTS TELLING US TO BUY BUY BUY AND YOUTUBE VIDEOS HAVE GOTTEN SLOWER BECAUSE OF THE EXTRA WEIGHT OF THE ADS! FACEBOOK AS WELL AS BLOGTV ENDURE THE SAME FATE AS THE NOW WASTELAND OF WHAT USED TO BE MYSPACE! IF OUR REQUESTS ARE NOT MET THERE WILL BE HELL TO PAY! ADS WILL FALL!