To Defrag Or Not To Defrag – That Is The Question?

Posted by on Mar 23, 2009 | 6 Comments

About 5 weeks ago I decided to try an experiment that was recommended by a reader. The basic was to defrag my system and than not to do any defragging for one month. Right after I decided to try this experiement I received a free evaluation copy courtesy of Diskeeper who provided me with a free copy of Diskeeper Pro Premier 2009 to try on my Vista laptop, which I used for the experiment.

My laptop is used through out the day for blogging, searching out sites and for playing with a variety of different softwares to test and review. So on about February 15th, 2009 I defragged by system using the Diskeeper product I mentioned above and did so for 5 days straight. On or about February 20th, 2009 I stopped defragging to see what would happen.

For the frist few weeks I didn’t notice much at all happening or I may not have been watching what was happening. But it was last week that I noticed a few things. I was going into Accessories – System Tools – System Information and I sat staring at an hour glass for about 10 seconds before anything came up. Strange I thought. When I opened some doc’s, same time warp but under 10 seconds and not so severe as above. This is when I noticed that even returning from hibernation also seemed slow. Was it my perception or were things really slowing down? A few more experiments and yes, things were slow. I finished out the remainder to my time and than defragged this morning.

All is once again well. Documents open quickly and I just tried system information and it came up immediately.

Does defragging really help a computer system? I believe it does but your mileage may vary.

Comments welcome.

  • Joe Abusamra

    Hi Ron,

    Good post. Another option for your defrag consideration is PerfectDisk.

    Joe Abusamra
    Raxco Software
    http://www.perfectdisk.com
    http://www.perfectdiskblog.com

  • Pingback: I Will Be Testing PerfectDisk By Raxco ~ The Blade by Ron Schenone, MVP

  • Buffet

    Diskkeeper is JUNK! If you wish to defragment properly, use PerfectDisk10

  • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

    Hi Buffet,
    Joe sent me a copy and I am trying it now.

  • Buffet

    I believe you’ll be pleasantly surprised. From following your column, I’ve noted that our views and opinions coincide more often than not. If I may sir, why is it that none of the writer’s avatars are displayed in the main body of Lockergnome’s newsletter, only when one clicks the link to the specific article? I always found that helpful.

  • http://wp3.lockergnome.com/nexus/blade/ Ron Schenone

    Hello Buffet,
    So far it appears PerfectDisk is going to get a 10/10.

    I’ll mention to Chris about including the avatars. If you look at the URL you will see the name of the blogs., ie. blade in the body for myself.

    I hope that helps some. Have a good one.

    Regards, Ron