Chinese Users Charge Microsoft As A Hacker
- 19
- Add a Comment
In China Microsoft has been battling piracy of its software products for years. I recall reading where in Beijing, Windows Vista sells on the street for as little as $2. But with Microsoft’s new Genuine Advantage program, some Chinese users are finding their systems have been hacked. The users are posting on blogs that Microsoft has hacked their computers and they now have a black screen which appears ever hour.
In China the bloggers are up in arms and have even asked the Chinese government to make Microsoft stop hacking their computers. The article also states that:
Dong Zhengwei, 35, a Beijing lawyer, has complained to the public security ministry, describing the software giant as the “biggest hacker in China, with its intrusion into users’ computer systems without their agreement or any judicial authority”.
He told the official China Daily newspaper that he believed the measure breached China’s criminal law, adding: “I respect the right of Microsoft to protect its intellectual property, but it is taking on the wrong target with wrong measures. They should target producers and sellers of fake software, not users.”
The China Software Industry Association said it also planned to take action against Microsoft, with director Chen Chong telling China Daily that the measure was “very bad”.
So what do you think? Do the Chinese people have a right to protest what Microsoft is doing? Or does Microsoft have the right to protect their property?
Comments welcome.

19 Comments
Lovs2look
October 23rd, 2008
at 1:43pm
You get what you pay for, even in China.
Ron Schenone
October 23rd, 2008
at 2:26pm
True.
Gandog
October 24th, 2008
at 8:13am
Use pirated software and die. Well done Microsoft.
zhu runrui
October 24th, 2008
at 9:10am
True and through!
Rick
October 24th, 2008
at 1:32pm
Microsoft was slammed in the court of public opinion a couple of years ago when they first fielded the WGA anti-piracy add-on to user’s PCs in the U.S. Now they’ve done the same in China, to similar fanfare. Apparently, theft is no longer considered a crime, either in China or the U.S…
From China, a country with a long-standing Communist streak painted down its back, I can understand that sort of reaction. After all, the people expect everything to be handed to them for no cost, being that under Marxist philosophy, everything belongs to everybody, regardless of the individuals’ drive, determination, industriousness, creativeness, intelligence, skills or talents. Brain surgeons and physicists have the same value and reap the same rewards as sloths and pan-handlers — in theory. So, the concepts of individual property rights and Intellectual Property rights may be completely foreign to them. Nevertheless, this doesn’t excuse the Chinese for their blatant disdain for individual and Intellectual Property rights, which are the societal norm in the rest of the world. And it doesn’t explain why citizens in a Capitalist Free-Market society, such as the U.S., are/were doing exactly the same thing.
Within Capitalist and Free-Market societies, citizens should be appalled to see such thought processes in action in their midst. But those same thought processes are very much alive and well within the US. One only needs to read blog posts which lambast and condemn the music and movie industries for attempting to defend their Intellectual Property rights. A huge number of American of IP thieves blatantly espouse rampant music and movie theft, actively sharing copyrighted materials through P2P networks at every opportunity without a single thought that what they are doing is felonious.
With such fine examples from deep within the heart of a Capitalist and Free-Market culture, can one blame the Chinese for their ignorance or disregard?
Mike
October 24th, 2008
at 1:54pm
I think they should delete the OS partition on the offender’s hard drive! When you buy pirate software you deserve nothing
Ole Man
October 24th, 2008
at 1:58pm
The Chinese are doing what US citizens SHOULD have done when Microsoft started automatically painting as guilty customers who had illegal copies of their software pawned off on them, and not even attempting to track down the REAL criminals.
Microsoft has no right to act as police, judge, and jury because software is such a new technology that regulatory laws are not yet present. Their activity is at least bordering on criminal if not outright criminal.
Microsoft has been allowed to conduct anti-trust activities until they think they can get away with anything, unchallenged.
Ron Schenone
October 24th, 2008
at 3:39pm
Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with us. It is appreciated.
Regards, Ron
Joe Bloe
October 24th, 2008
at 4:08pm
I’m glad the Chinese are taking this sort of action against Micro$haft. Micro$haft is the biggest bully in the world and have created the most oppressive licensing agreements known to man. You can’t even buy a PC laptop computer unless it is pre-loaded with that crummy Vista so-called operating system, and [I believe] if you reformat your laptop and XP (or whatever), the warranty is void.
Bill Gate$ is worth around $100 billion. Why is he so greedy that he wants to dive into the pockets of people who go from paycheck to paycheck? Screw Micro$haft.
Software Developer
October 24th, 2008
at 7:36pm
It’s actually a tough call.
Microsoft does not own the targeted PCs. Therefore, if they are externally altering other peoples’ property and interfering with their life then they are to be blamed. And they would be guilty of “hacking”.
(However, if the software was programmed to do this from the beginning, then they are not guilty of trespass.)
The Chinese users appear to have taken what was not theirs. So they are to be blamed because they have failed to justly reward the Microsoft workers for the work of their hands.
Never do two wrongs make a right.
Side note: Whomever designed the script that prevents this comment box from responding to the arrow keys & backspace has done me a disservice.
E2001
October 26th, 2008
at 7:43pm
I think if the Chinese are so worried about Microsoft “hacking” their hacked OSes; then they should go back to using XP. It’s easier to hack.
Dave Simpson
October 26th, 2008
at 7:47pm
From the report, nobody is running counterfeit software. They are complaining about Micro$oft entering their pc without invitation. This is common - unfortunately. Doesn’t anyone recall a few months ago, some users were complaining they had updates turned off - yet Micro$oft simply FORCED an upgrade/patch onto their pc? The dude noticed he was downloading something, yet he had not initiated anything. So he reported it etc..
From memory the way to stop this is to disable WGA.
El Pelon
October 27th, 2008
at 4:15am
Vista for two bucks? Still a bit overpriced, but certainly a better deal than the poor schmoes in America are paying
Ron Schenone
October 27th, 2008
at 5:35am
Thanks for all of the comments. I appreciate all of you taking the time to share your thoughts with us.
Regards, Ron
M. Free
October 28th, 2008
at 11:30am
OMG! C’mon people, Microsoft is in business to MAKE a PROFIT. Without profit, there is no business. If we do not protect our businesses, we are doomed. If you do not like the product, or the price, there are alternatives, some of them are free, so, you have a choice. Yes, if a Chinese or any individual really believed that they were getting the genuine article, then they shouldn’t be blamed, but for $2, even the Chinese know better.
M. Free
Ron Schenone
October 28th, 2008
at 12:40pm
Hi M.Free,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Shtanto
October 28th, 2008
at 3:06pm
In China, a 10kg bale of recycled rubish might sell for $2.
In China, you can buy Windows Vista for $2.
Logically speaking, Windows Vista is recycled rubbish.
Doug Tucker
October 31st, 2008
at 6:42am
Joe Bloe is an idiot. Would any company produce a product, then let people steal it? If so, joe should send out a billion free samples:) I’ve been an IT Consultant/Engineer for 17years. I’ve been on the front-line with Microsoft’s licensing issues. Yes it is a problem for those who can’t afford to buy legitimate software. The only thing I see, regarding the Chinese, is that in my arena, most of the hacking attempts blocked by my firewall originate from China. China difinately is abusing the world using stolen software.
About Vista; Every new operating system has initial flaws. I’m not a Vista fan…. every system I order is ordered with an XP downgrade. You have to search for hardware that offers another choice of OS.
Sorry for the hate. Just can’t stand the “screaming MeMe”
Doug Tucker
October 31st, 2008
at 6:50am
Continued, Bill Gates is a generous Philanthropists