E-Mail:
Author Avatar

What Happened To Microsoft’s Windows Home Server?

It started out with a bang. During the beta testing I was excited by the prospect that home users could take advantage of a home server that would automatically backup ALL the computers on a network. The software was simple to use and held great promise. But than the problems started to surface. People started to report file corruption issues. The folks at the Home Server unit of Microsoft took on the problem, but it took so many updates and attempts at fixes that some of us gave up on the software.

So is the Channel ready to embrace Windows Home Server? According to this article, everyone is waiting for Microsoft to start advertising the operating system and embark on a media blitz.

Susan Bradley, a Small Business Specialist partner in Fresno, Calif., describes Home Server as a “strong” product, but says she’s “honestly concerned” about the amount of marketing Microsoft has devoted to the product thus far.

For example, in a recent visit to the Innoventions Dream Home, an exhibit in the Anaheim, Calif.-based theme park Tomorrowland that includesHP (NYSE: HPQ)’s Media SmartServer (which runs on Home Server), Bradley was surprised by the distinct lack of Home Server branding.

“I knew that there was a Windows Home Server featured in the exhibit, but unless you know what the [HP Media SmartServer] looks like, you’d never know that there was a Home Server there, or that Microsoft was a key player,” said Bradley. 

Other partners aren’t sure if Microsoft will ever be able to create demand for the Home Server segment, simply because most home users’ needs can be met by solutions that are less expensive but still meet the majority of users’ needs

“I could see competitors like Linksys beating Windows Home Server by releasing a router with a 500 gigabyte hard drive that’s managed from a Web browser,” he said. 

 There you have it. Opinions from Channel partners that reflect a lack of confidence in whether consumers will even want to use Windows Home Server. I believe what is disappointing is that it took a very long time for a Power Pack to be introduced and some doubt lingers that the bugs are completely ironed out.

I personally dumped the software and went back to backing up my systems manually. But what do you think?

Comments welcome.

Source.

6 Comments

WHS was a complete bust for me. I built a new1 terabyte server just before the software was released. Once I had the media, I installed it as directed. Almost from the beginning, the troubles started. The server would not recognize one of the laptops. It refused to backup the desktop then it refused to backup the most important storage drive on my network. I fussed with it, I tweaked it, I heartily cursed it and then I re-installed it. Same results …. I finally just gave up on it. I wiped the drive and installed XP Pro on the server and, like you, manually backup the important drives and files and have not a single issue since. However, I must say that my rear-end is still a little pained from the cost and failure of WHS. I really wanted that product to work for me!

Hi Bruce,
Do you think you will try it again using the Power Pack?

Regards, Ron

Things are just working now, I’m a little adverse to messing that up in hopes it *may* work out. So - short term, nope. Long term - well, never say never….

Yes, I think that Microsoft needs to step up to the plate and do some major remedial marketing for this product. It’s a shame that such a great product idea got a black eye early in the process.

I have a MediaSmart Server, and I love it. Now that PP1 is out, and HP also provided the long-awaited update (including McAfee AV), the whole thing works great.

I also added the Drive Labeler add-in which I found on MediaSmartHome.com.

Hello,

I think the main stumbling block for Windows Home Server was the data corruption bug. Since Windows Home Servers are meant to be sold as turnkey devices, many manufacturers probably just stopped working on it, not wanting to ship a device which would not sell and have a high return rate when they did.

Now that the issue has been addressed, I suspect that we will see more of a push for such devices around the holiday season, when families typically look at making their big ticket consumer electronics purchases.

Regards,

Aryeh Goretsky

Thanks Aryeh for sharing your thoughts with us.

What Do You Think?

 


Anti-Spam Image

Want to Start a Blog Here for Free?

Are you an expert in one subject or another? If your goal is to help others and dispense hard-earned information back to the community, stake a claim on your very own Lockergnome blog today! You can write about anything - no matter the topic. Sign-up to start blogging!

61 queries / 0.403 seconds.