Windows Vista SP1 Improves The UAC Experience
- 2
- Add a Comment
For those who are using Microsoft’s Windows Vista RTM, you are more than familiar with UAC [User Account Control]. This little gem prompts you the user anytime you wish to complete a task in the Vista operating system. The original purpose I believe was to provide added security to Vista in the hopes of protecting the user from unwanted actions, that could indicate the presence of a rogue program.
With the RTM version of Vista, to complete a simple task such as creating a new folder, it required 4 separate actions to complete. The user needed to click on 4 separate UAC screens. Needless to say this was annoying for some. But over at Microsoft Technet, this process has now been cut down to just once UAC screen and prompt for those who upgraded to SP1.
There is a short video in various formats for you to take a look at and to observe the improvements. Hopefully this will be carried over to Windows 7.
Do you think that this is a step in the right direction? Or do you still feel that UAC is still a pain?
Comments welcome.

2 Comments
Ryan
June 4th, 2008
at 6:41pm
UAC is far too annoying and chatty, most of it’s apologists argue that it’s like Sudo for Linux, even though UAC is not in the same league, and I’ve never been so aggravated by Sudo that I’d wanted rid of it, and Sudo does not pester you for your password for every operation.
Example, in Windows I want to delete 4 files, 1 in each subdirectory, I get 4 UAC prompts.
In Linux, that hardly happens, because your system files are quite well seperated from user files and apt-get purge will delete the program’s whole folder, and clean up the config files, so there are actually fewer per-incident reasons to invoke Sudo than UAC, as UAC must operate under the Windows environment, where Microsoft has thrown anything remotely like security to the wind, until 2004, whereas security has been part of the UNIX design, since the 1970’s.
But about UAC being less annoying in SP1 vs RTM, it’s about the same really, the first thing I did was disable it, of course I feel I know what the hell I’m doing with the system, and I’m sure a lot of people that use Windows really just don’t, and so for them, leaving it on may be the better choice, but UAC in any event, makes my blood boil.
Ron Schenone
June 5th, 2008
at 4:58am
Heh Ryan,
Thanks for sharing you thoughts with us.